Mexican prosecutors investigate possible Frida Kahlo fakes featured in 2 art history books
By Catherine E. Shoichet, APTuesday, September 22, 2009
Mexican prosecutors probe possible Frida fakes
MEXICO CITY — Mexican federal prosecutors said Tuesday they are investigating a claim that more than 1,000 items attributed to artist Frida Kahlo were forged.
The Diego Rivera and Frida Kahlo Trust filed a complaint saying signed paintings, notes and drawings featured in two recent art history books are fake, the Attorney General’s Office said.
“We must stop the commercialization of false works,” said Hilda Trujillo, director of the Diego Rivera and Frida Kahlo Museums.
The works in question come from a private collection and appear in two books, “Finding Frida Kahlo” and “The Labyrinth of Frida Kahlo: Death, Pain and Ambivalence.”
Kahlo, who died in 1954, was known for her tortured self-portraits and a tumultuous relationship with Mexican muralist Diego Rivera, who she married.
Katharine Myers at Princeton Architectural Press, the publisher of “Finding Frida Kahlo,” said it plans to keep selling the book.
“In the book, we state that the pieces have not been 100 percent authenticated, that it’s still being researched,” Myers said.
Members of the trust and some art history scholars hope the publishers will take the books off the market, saying at a news conference in Mexico City that the consequences could be severe if the books keep being sold.
“This will infect all the studies of Frida Kahlo with a virus, with bad, inaccurate information,” said James Oles, an assistant professor at Wellesley College who has joined with other art historians in criticizing the publications.
The owners of the art, according to Oles, say the collection came from five boxes that Kahlo gave to a carpenter.
Oles said items in the collection include significant spelling errors, low-quality paintings and other suspicious details.
“What woman signs her recipes? No one, unless they want to sell them,” he said.
Associated Press writer Istra Pacheco contributed to this report.
Tags: Art History, Central America, Latin America And Caribbean, Mexico, Mexico City, North America, Painting, Visual Arts And Design
October 4, 2009: 9:58 pm
I guess the collection is a good enough fake to fool the artists Bustos, Lazo ,Estrada famous muralists in their own right who spent over 10 years studying and working with Frida and Diego and were their intimate friends.They read every letter and studied each piece firsthand and certified the collection as authentic. I guess it fooled one of Mexico’s preeminent scientists, Javier Vasquez Negrete, who dated 10 paintings to the 1940s at a time when it was hard for Frida to sell her own work and much less likely for someone to be forging her work. I guess they fooled Ruth Alvarado Rivera ,Diego’s granddaughter who also studied the collection firsthand.I guess it fooled Abraham Dergal a certified handwriting analyst for Mexico’s Superior court who said that this is the writing of Frida Kahlo. The provenance has been proven, the collection having belonged to a well known wood sculptor who worked with Diego and was a close friend of Frida’s , Abraham Jimenez Lopez. The critics can say what they want . None have seen the collection firsthand or even begun the proper studies to authenticate or disqualify a work of art much less a collection. — Jed Paradies |
Jed Paradies